BlackBerry Tries Money Messaging with BBM Money

Pilot in Indonesia Will Be Popular, But BlackBerry Must Consider Next Step


Last week the commercial pilot of BlackBerry's BBM Money launched in Indonesia. The service allows BlackBerry Messenger (BBM) users to make person-to-person payments in a similar way to the M-Pesa service in Kenya. Users can open BBM, select a BBM contact and transfer money to them in real time.

I hadn't initially expected BlackBerry to enter mobile payments. Handset manufacturers are not known to deploy their own independent mobile payment services. Only Nokia has tried, and its Nokia Money service lasted for about two years before closing down. (Although it's worth pointing out that this was more a result of Nokia's overall changing strategy in mobile rather than a failure of the service.)

Today handset manufacturers that are working in mobile payments are usually collaborating with other companies to provide the rest of the hardware for transactions. Most recent examples include Samsung, which worked with Visa to enable payments on Galaxy S III models at the London Olympics 2012.

bbm_money_logosCloser examination reveals that BlackBerry has actually taken a similar approach for BBM Money. The service stems from collaboration between PermataBank in Indonesia and UK technology company Monitise. BBM is essentially being used as a portal to facilitate digital payment transactions.

BBM Money could do quite well in Indonesia, but I think there are a couple of reasons why BlackBerry needs to treat any success with caution. Firstly, BlackBerry enjoys immense popularity in Indonesia, accounting for more than half the smartphone market. So customer response is not likely to be representative of the global market.

Secondly, mobile payment services are generally quite popular in emerging markets because of a lack of banking infrastructure. Users in Indonesia will be more willing — or have more need — to try such services.

Looking beyond Indonesia, I'm not sure whether BBM Money in its current form would fare as well in other countries. Services like mobile payments really need scale to lift off, but BBM Money is restricted to BlackBerry handsets. Indonesia may be a booming market for BlackBerry, but this isn't the case in Europe and the US, for example.

From my own experience of using BBM to message friends and relatives in different countries, I think the next step for BBM Money is to focus on cross-border mobile payment services. Of course, international mobile payments face considerable legal and regulatory challenges. Perhaps a partnership with an international payments company like Western Union would work.

Just as BBM provided a great new messaging application exclusive to BlackBerry users across the globe, I think BBM Money has the potential to also offer a truly innovative service.

This entry was posted on February 21st, 2013 and is filed under Services. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Digantam Gurung On February 21st, 2013


Comments
(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
What to expect at IFA in Berlin next week http://t.co/gVWNCGXhCj (log-in requ'd)
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
Interesting move from @VodafoneUK PAYG #4G. £79.99 smartphone. £20 gets 2GB data, unlimited texts and 500 mins. http://t.co/uz1Yk6bHed
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
More disruption in UK mobile retail: “@Mobile_Mag: Vodafone drops @Phones4u and deal with @DixonsCarphone signed http://t.co/4TGNMJeunF”
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
@here - important win with @Samsung for Tizen devices and Android Galaxy phones. Helps cement @here's position as the anti-Google for maps.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
If only all execs were as straight forward as Huawei's Richard Yu. "Tizen has no chance to be successful" http://t.co/uFKERaFESV
Follow Geoff
Arnaud Gagneux
RT @CCSInsight: Forecast predicts global tablet sales to stutter in 2014, but replacement to drive new growth http://t.co/djy010SCXP http:/…
Follow Arnaud
Paolo Pescatore
Missing full @SkySportsF1 TV coverage this weekend. Will try 2 rely on @SkySports & @thomsonreuters Sports Reel apps http://t.co/JY4kvUTYN6
Follow Paolo
Kester Mann
RT @DixonsCarphone: Dixons Carphone can confirm it has recently signed a new long term agreement with Vodafone. Includes an enhanced distri…
Follow Kester
Jasdeep Badyal
Good sales of the HTC One M8 in 2Q14 but still a long road ahead for #HTC http://t.co/dALHk0uM2s @Mobile_Mag
Follow Jasdeep
George Jijiashvili
ASUS confirms its Android Wear smartwatch will have $199 price band [http://t.co/88bYMVDAqk] #wearables #wearabletech http://t.co/5xgSk7JZBe
Follow George

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
When Legacy Players Bide Their Time Is Swatch Looking Down the Barrel of Disruption? Ten ye... Read more
Blog Post
Is the Stylus Back in Style? Despite Hero Devices, Pen Input Isn't a KSP The touching ... Read more
Blog Post
Pie or Squared? Which Smartwatch Shape Will Prevail? This autumn will be ... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Smartwatches and Smart Bands Dominate Fast-Growing Wearables Market Wearables Shipments to Hit 22 Million in 2014 up 129% from 2... Read more
More news