Finding a Standard for Mobile Barcodes

I've been handing out my new business cards over the past week or so. People are initially bemused by the mobile barcode on the back. Once I show them how it can be read with a camera phone and turned into an e-mail address, telephone number or Web address, they're usually impressed. As I wrote in a previous blog post, mobile barcodes are a great way to convey information (as long as you don't try to cram too much into them).

But the technology's not without its limitations. When deciding what to put on out our business cards, we were faced with a number of choices: QR or Semacodes? Telephone number or e-mail address? Web site? All three?

We chose QR codes because they're more widely supported in the Far East but still work with many reader applications here in Europe. As for content, the freeform nature of 2D barcodes means there are few standards when it comes to the encoded information. Most phones use the vCard format when sending contact information via Bluetooth, but the format hasn't made it to mobile barcode readers yet. I think it's only a matter of time before it does — as mobile barcodes become more widespread, manufacturers will support standards like vCard and vCal.

Back of CCS Insight business card

In the absence of any obvious standards, we decided to encode our individual e-mail addresses, telephone numbers and a link to our Web site into the barcode. To the right is the back of one of our cards. We left off vCard tags because they appear as (fairly) meaningless extra text in the decoded information. In Nokia's S60 Barcode application, each piece of information appears as a link. Clicking on it brings up a list of options: create message, save to contacts and so on. It's a good example of how to integrate applications on a phone, and I think the addition of vCard and vCal support would be a welcome bonus.

Of course, for mobile barcode technology to be effective, you have to have barcodes printed on things and applications that can read them. That means designing new stationery and upgrading phone hardware and software. In many cases, tried and tested methods of getting information into phones — such as texting "info" to a shortcode — are more obvious and immediate. No matter how sophisticated applications become, there'll always be a place for quick and direct methods.

I wouldn't be surprised if we see more phones take the approach favoured by the likes of Sony Ericsson's P990i and P1 and Samsung's Omnia i900, which have integrated applications that use optical character recognition (OCR) technology to read ordinary business cards. They don't rely on special codes and are more likely to appeal to non-technical users.

Given that OCR is a mature technology in the PC environment, and that some smartphones sport more processing power than the first desktop OCR systems, mobile codes may be a short-lived phenomenon. Once every phone has enough resources to run a full OCR application, QR and Semacodes could be consigned to mobile history.

This entry was posted on August 19th, 2008 and is filed under Devices. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Robert Caunt On August 19th, 2008


Comments
- 2008-08-19 at 20:29
Hate to say it, but why isn't anyone making a service where you can make a barcode that points to a hosted vCard that you can edit quite easily from your computer?
Rob
- 2008-08-20 at 19:59
Hi Stefan I guess you could create a mobile barcode that points to a URL (www.ccsinsight.com/mycard.vcf, as a fictional example) and then point people to that. As you say, you'd have to be able to edit it easily. And the recipient would have to have Internet access to download the card. All in all, it's a pretty convoluted method of giving someone your contact details. I think standard paper business cards will be with us for a while yet. Rob
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
Smart footwear has yet to gain broad appeal, but we expect this #wearables segment to continue to show steady growth https://t.co/qAprwZR9A3
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @SteveRattner: Amazing: 1990: top 3 automakers: Revenues: $250B Employees: 1.2M 2014: top 3 Silicon Valley co’s: Revenues: $250B E…
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
RT @nickmcquire: SoftBank invests $100m in @cybereason. Big
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
@Intel going in big with Olympic sponsorship, as a showcase for lots of core future technologies.… https://t.co/XWX8Ygo5Cv
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
RT @SteveRattner: Amazing: 1990: top 3 automakers: Revenues: $250B Employees: 1.2M 2014: top 3 Silicon Valley co’s: Revenues: $250B E…
Follow Geoff
Marina Koytcheva
@Herring1967 You are not alone :)
Follow Marina
Nicholas McQuire
SoftBank invests $100m in @cybereason. Big
Follow Nicholas
Paolo Pescatore
Another telco partner for #Netflix. Interesting approach taken by @WindTreOfficial, bundled package incl Google Chr… https://t.co/NapQQLXC4o
Follow Paolo
Kester Mann
Veon is breaking new ground with a radical new strategy. What are its chances to succeed? Full analysis in CCS Insi… https://t.co/Tith3Ul9VZ
Follow Kester
George Jijiashvili
Connected footwear is seeing a comeback after several failed attempts to introduce them to mainstream [… https://t.co/0JpjX7Cc2h
Follow George
Katie Taylor
RT @GdnPolitics: Whether you are calling it #BattleForNumber10 or #mayvcorbyn, don't forget to play along at home https://t.co/Aj4SG7lkaS h…
Follow Katie
Tony Worthington
@MassiveAttackUK I did my university dissertation on this when we had, ahem, floppy disks. Happy to send a copy. Good read.
Follow Tony

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
The Resurgence of Smart Footwear New Generation of Connected Shoes Will Boost Demand In the ... Read more
Blog Post
Did Sprint Borrow a Page from Jio's Playbook? Offer of Free LTE Looks Familiar Through a low-key marketin... Read more
Blog Post
Is AR Coming of Age or Still Just a Promise? Industry Cooperation Will Be Crucial to Success AR has been... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Sales of 5G Smartphones to Hit 100 Million in 2021 Over 10 billion mobile phones to be shipped in the next five... Read more
More news