Five Easy Pieces

Will the Modular Phone Concept Ever Come Together?


Has mass production met a mighty foe in modularity?

The modular phone concept is an intriguing idea: simply buy the hardware features you want now, and upgrade with satisfying snap-on components like better speakers, bigger batteries and health care sensors. This system camera-like architecture isn't completely new to the handset business — smartphone owners can already customise their devices with SIM cards and SD cards, Square Readers, colourful cases and, of course, apps. Paul Eremenko, Google's visionary head of Project Ara, wants to further this by enabling a hardware bazaar of interchangeable gadgets that sit snugly on a Google-made "endoskeleton".

Mr Eremenko spoke last week about his long-term ambitions for modular phones. He expects the devices to disrupt the smartphone industry entirely, bringing the basic building blocks to users and enabling them to add to these according to their needs and budgets. Mr Eremenko expects that Wi-Fi-enabled endoskeletons will be available from Google for $50 from as early as 2015. A beta version of the Module Developers Kit is already available for download, and the company is offering a $100,000 prize for what it judges as the most innovative Project Ara module.

This is impressive forward momentum, but CCS Insight believes that the economic and logistical challenges of modular phones will be difficult to overcome (see Google Launches Build-Your-Own-Phone Project Ara) and that Google's energies to bring connected devices to another 5 billion users could be better spent. We understand that certain new technologies (such as functional 3G printing) are interesting developments for the industry, but the efficiency of mass-produced phones built with standardised components will be the greatest competitive hurdle for modular devices to overcome.

Project Ara is also competing with Google's Android One, which aims to introduce low-cost devices to billions, and Firefox has unveiled its own ambition to bring the $25 smartphone to developing markets.

Handset modularity hasn't had a smooth past. In 2007, Israeli-based Modu sparked interest in modular phones with the concept of "jackets" — enclosure into which the phone's core was inserted. However, the company folded in 2011, and Google purchased several of its patents. We have since seen a series of modular projects from several major handset manufacturers, but few of these have gone ahead; Xiaomi's Magic Cube and ZTE's Eco Mobius project are examples of modular phone ventures that are very unlikely to reach realisation.

There's no doubt that Project Ara could grow in ways not even Google could imagine. However, if the intentions are to find an innovative way to spread connectivity across the globe in an environmentally conscious manner (as the company states), we believe that Google would be better off supporting a robust secondary market for devices, and continuing to expand its partnerships with manufacturers. For now, the theories and realities of modularity are still too far apart.

This entry was posted on June 30th, 2014 and is filed under Devices. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Peter Bryer On June 30th, 2014

(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
IBM's @IBMWatson engine says it's going to be a mobile Black Friday
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @George_CCS: Free VR headsets all around this holiday season! This one from @EE for #blackfriday #wearables #cardboard…
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
RT @George_CCS: Free VR headsets all around this holiday season! This one from @EE for #blackfriday #wearables #cardboard…
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
20%: the battery life left on a @dell #XPS13 on landing at SFO from Heathrow, having spent much of the flight using Excel. Awesome.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
Intriguing. Google applying to FCC for a license to test in 28Ghz and 31Ghz bands
Follow Geoff
Nicholas McQuire
Love Network Rail's mobility strategy & journey> #NetworkRail rolls out 22k iPhones & iPads, en route to wearables
Follow Nicholas
Paolo Pescatore
Huge loss to @canalplus. Not only loosing subs but key content rights as well. Massive coup for Altice, #4K too!
Follow Paolo
Marina Koytcheva
And now BBC's predictions for 2035: even bolder than @CCSinsight 's? :)
Follow Marina
Kester Mann
Free overtook Bouygues in 3Q15 based on total subs. Incredible market impact given launch was less than 4 years ago!
Follow Kester
Jasdeep Badyal
RT @benwood: Nice to see @FT's @DanielThomasLDN picking up @CCSInsight predictions in this morning's paper! #ccspredicts…
Follow Jasdeep
George Jijiashvili
Following successful 'Free Power Bar' promotion, @EE is giving away VR headsets to increase footfall #wearables
Follow George
Rebecca Morley
CCS’s yearly forecast sees telecoms mergers and rise of wearables -
Follow Rebecca
Katie Taylor
Nine questions about ISIS you were too embarrassed to ask via @voxdotcom
Follow Katie

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
Watson Says It's Mobile Black Friday In the US, One Third of E-Commerce Sales Will Come from Mobi... Read more
Blog Post
The Leisure Class of Wearables The Travel Industry and Smart Bands: A Perfect Fit German... Read more
Blog Post
Loon Launch Google's Big Float The concept of floating base stations ... Read more
More blog