NFC Trials in Milan

Telecom Italia's Variety of NFC Applications Provide Fresh Optimism


During last week's GSMA NFC and Mobile Money Summit in Milan, I was fortunate to be selected as one of the 1,000 pilot participants of Telecom Italia's NFC trial. Having previously been an early adopter of Orange's Quick Tap in the UK, I was eager to see how mobile payments might differ in another country and whether this might change my attitude to NFC-based mobile payments, for better or worse.

On receiving a Samsung Galaxy Mini 2 NFC for the trial, I was immediately impressed by the variety of NFC uses that were being promoted by Telecom Italia. Unlike Orange Quick Tap, which was primarily limited to in-store payments, the Italian initiative includes public transport, coupons, smart posters and even an interactive NFC visit at the Museum of Science and Technology.

It was encouraging to see NFC being used for so many different things. I don't think the technology should be restricted to mobile payments; if anything, non-payment uses of NFC will probably be more popular in the short term. However, given the scale of this pilot, I was slightly apprehensive whether all the advertised services would work.

Of course, mobile payments were the focus of the show, and so I had to try this first at a local retailer. Using my TIM Wallet app preloaded with €15, I found a nearby participating restaurant to have dinner.

Unfortunately the staff was not familiar with the technology and couldn't process the transaction. But I did get some satisfaction from using my 10 percent discount coupon saved on the app. The discount was applied by tapping my Galaxy Mini 2 against the waiter's Galaxy Mini 2, which I assume was connected to the restaurant's point-of-sale system.

Despite this initial hiccup, I was determined to find other uses for NFC the next day.

One interesting example was exchanging business cards between NFC phones. This certainly had its benefits — I met many people that had run out of physical business cards — but performing the transaction was not straightforward. Many attendees at the event struggled to understand how to set up the phone to make the exchange.

milan_nfc

It wasn't all disappointing. In just two days in Milan, I encountered notable successes with my NFC-enabled device. The phone was easily able to read smart posters and connect to the Web links. I was most impressed with the NFC ticket on the phone, which provided two one-day travel passes. I used it to get on the metro and it worked perfectly. I simply waved the phone over the card reader at the ticket barrier (see left). I can already see this would offer a number of benefits to commuters.

NFC ticketing is arguably one of the best usage scenarios for the technology. Early trials, such as the one in London using a Nokia 6131 NFC phone in 2007 and 2008, focussed on this aspect and contributed greatly to raising the profile of NFC. I believe there's still a lot of potential in this area, particularly in London where similar technology is already used on the city's Oyster Card.

So, how did my Italian experience differ from my use of Orange Quick Tap in the UK? Certainly Telecom Italia has provided a variety of very interesting ideas that I think could work well in many cities in the UK. NFC ticketing, which is seeing greater adoption, definitely deserves more attention.

Yet some problems persist, most notably in the area of payments. I'm not sure if my experience in Milan changed my fundamental views on NFC, but it has left me optimistic about what could be achieved with the technology. Judging by the variety and number of attendees at NFC and Mobile Money Summit 2012, I don't think I'm the only one.

This entry was posted on October 31st, 2012 and is filed under Services. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Digantam Gurung On October 31st, 2012


Comments
(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
LG might come to rival Samsung in bringing 3G-enabled smartwatches to market, rumours suggest http://t.co/mQOCesQoCr
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
Looking forward to speaking at KPN Lets Talk Business 2014 next week alongside @johnvanvianen http://t.co/JDq4N2ugfm #ltbkpn
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
Samsung UK sweetening deal on Galaxy Alpha with a £50 e-voucher when you buy at any UK retailer. @SamsungMobile http://t.co/PQmC8J1MMl
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
@Insteon launches connected home kits in US selling in @Microsoft store, app on Windows Phone with Cortana integration. Good news for WP.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
#Windows10 realizes the vision of one Windows. Windows 10 will also be the next version of Windows Phone. Crucial in battle for developers
Follow Geoff
Arnaud Gagneux
RT @corentin_lamy: J'ai continué mon petit comparo entre les offres @netflix US et @NetflixFR, et c'est pas foufou http://t.co/Is82rkAgYO
Follow Arnaud
Paolo Pescatore
RT @shauncollins: Delighted to announce @nickmcquire joins @CCSInsight as VP Enterprise. Exciting times for the team. http://t.co/gcI0PRxNPS
Follow Paolo
Nicholas McQuire
Microsoft's official blog on #Windows10 for enterprise http://t.co/2aRfKNUw7g
Follow Nicholas
Kester Mann
"O2 can disrupt in the UK public sector market," says @bendowdo2com. "Many organisations here still use feature phones!" #TefEuroIADay
Follow Kester
Jasdeep Badyal
RT @benwood: Exploded camera lens graphics standard part of any flagship launch these days. Nokia pioneered it - how times change http://t.…
Follow Jasdeep
George Jijiashvili
RT @shauncollins: Delighted to announce @nickmcquire joins @CCSInsight as VP Enterprise. Exciting times for the team. http://t.co/gcI0PRxNPS
Follow George

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
No Time to Jump to Conclusions Might LG Join Samsung in the Adult Watch–Phone Market? ... Read more
Blog Post
New Research, New Opportunities Nick McQuire Joins CCS Insight to Lead New Enterprise Resear... Read more
Blog Post
A Social Revolution or Flavour of the Month? Will Ello Mean Facebook's Goodbye? Ello earned its stripe... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Nicholas McQuire Joins CCS Insight to Lead New Enterprise Research Service Research Coverage Continues to Expand CCS Insight is please... Read more
More news