Why the mobile phone industry needs Motorola

Motorola’s current difficulties have got the doom-merchants chattering about a collapse similar to that experienced by Siemens and its subsequent disastrous sale to BenQ. At this stage these comparisons are nothing short of ridiculous.

Motorola is in a very different situation to BenQ-Siemens which found itself stuck as a “bottom feeder” trying to sell entry levels phones in an increasingly competitive market. The company lacked the scale to compete with Nokia which still controls this segment and most importantly its margins. Once Nokia dropped its prices by a few percent BenQ-Siemens was toast.

Motorola still has 12 percent market share (admittedly dramatically smaller than the 22.1 percent it had back in 2006) as well as a strong brand, global distribution, engineering and design capabilities and intellectual property. It is the market leader in the high value US market and is well known in major growth markets such as China, India and Brazil.

That said there is no denying the problems it currently has. Sadly it has fallen into the same trap that has blighted it in the past. The company seems to have a heritage of delivering “firework” products – the huge rocket goes up into the sky at the end of a firework display, the kids hold their breath in expectation and then there is a massive bang and eye dazzling display that wows the crowd – the best of the evening…. – and then that’s it…

There are several distinct examples of such products in Motorola’s history (see pictures below). The company defined the original mobile phone with its DynaTAC phone and built a dominant market share. By 1994 it had 32.5% market share versus Nokia which had approximately 21%. Further products emerged – the famous flip phone (Motorola MicroTAC) but Motorola relied too much on this design and was also late adopting GSM – this hurt its market share but it managed to deliver the StarTAC in 1996 continuing to hold off Nokia (26% share versus 20%). Nokia’s share even dropped a little in 1997 but quickly overhauled Motorola in 1998 when it failed to deliver a compelling successor to the StarTAC.

Fast forward to 2004 and Motorola’s share had dropped to 15%– BOOM! – it launches the RAZR and takes the market by storm – by 2006 it has 22.1% share but once again it had no answer once the RAZR burned out. Motorola had failed to learn lessons from the StarTAC and its over-confidence led to it becoming completely dependent on the design.

So why is this important and why do we need Motorola to get back on its feet? Well all the phones above had a disruptive impact on the market. The DynaTAC was the first truly “mobile” phone. The world fell in love with the “flip” phone when the MicroTAC was announced and the StarTAC looked like it had come from Star Trek. As for the RAZR – it defined “thin” and “fashion” (remember that pink version) but as was the case in the past – all the competitors just learnt from Motorola and piled on the pressure.

Motorola needs a new hero product – but this time it must make sure that it avoids any complacency and has the foresight to make sure that rather than putting all its eggs in one basket it has a portfolio of products that can compete on every level. Can it deliver this? Let’s hope so because a mobile phone industry without Motorola would be a little less great than it is today.

Motorola DynaTAC

Motorola DynaTAC

Motorola MicroTAC

Motorola MicroTAC

Motorola StarTAC

Motorola StarTAC

Motorola RAZR

Motorola RAZR

Pink RAZR

Motorola Pink RAZR V3

This entry was posted on February 9th, 2008 and is filed under Devices. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Ben Wood On February 9th, 2008


Comments
(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
US car-maker @GM seeks to accelerate its self-driving programme by acquiring lidar start-up Strobe: https://t.co/QXcEj4m2v1
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @LauraSimeonova: Mobile News on CCS Insight's latest Mobile Phone Forecast - https://t.co/OT6kj6LGfw
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
RT @geoffblaber: Thoughts on Google using #gigabitLTE to help differentiate Android devices https://t.co/4ttBQerUmG
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
@Microsoft + @awscloud collaborate on new deep learning tool, Gluon. https://t.co/XiaefK2k1w. Easier to experiment with neural nets.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
RT @paolopescatore: Another good quarter for Netflix. Higher subs but next quarter could be challenging due to price rises. Content costs o…
Follow Geoff
Marina Koytcheva
Thank you @TriumphUK for helping sort out an annoying situation. I appreciate your quick and effective assistance!
Follow Marina
Nicholas McQuire
Here's a good summary of the AWS & Microsoft #DeepLearning collaboration with our comments from @mobilityxchange https://t.co/nUkGM1m3bV
Follow Nicholas
Paolo Pescatore
Another good quarter for Netflix. Higher subs but next quarter could be challenging due to price rises. Content costs ongoing concern $NFLX
Follow Paolo
Kester Mann
RT @paolopescatore: Light reading ahead of the weekend, my thoughts on forthcoming Premier League rights auction #PL #OTT #video https://t.…
Follow Kester
Laura Simeonova
RT @benwood: Big news from Samsung overnight. Despite strong profits CEO resigns. Cites concerns over future challenges. https://t.co/bqI1…
Follow Laura
Katie Taylor
RT @TheBMA: Two junior doctors were left looking after more than 400 patients during very unsafe shift at stretched hospital https://t.co/q…
Follow Katie

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
General Motors to Focus on Autonomous Cars Acquires Strobe, a Lidar Technology Start-Up Fully autonomo... Read more
Blog Post
Web Giants Eye Rights to Football Matches Upcoming Premier League Rights Auction Set to Spark Bidding ... Read more
Blog Post
Project Loon to the Rescue Alphabet Balloons to Offer Emergency Cellular Service in Pue... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

More news