Android at CES 2012: The Unspoken Reality

Huge Support for Google's Platform Could Benefit Microsoft

 

As predicted, this year's Consumer Electronics Show (CES) is dominated by Android. Google's platform can be seen on the lion's share of smartphones and tablets, not to mention TVs and other connected devices. It's a clear illustration of Android's dominance and the breadth of support from partners and developers.

At least, that's how it appears. Few can question what Google has achieved and Android's phenomenal position, particularly in smartphones. But the operating system faces fundamental challenges that the hordes at CES can't see or, more likely, choose to ignore.

This isn't the first time CCS Insight has pointed out that Android is unsustainable in its current form. Scope for differentiation is limited and essentially disappearing as a combination of the pressure to get products on the market and Google's need for control restricts manufacturers' ability to set their products apart from other Android-powered devices.

A lucky few, such as Samsung, Sony and HTC, have the assets or financial means to invest in their own services, but this is a risky and capital-intensive approach, as Nokia can testify. And the likes of Facebook, Amazon and Google are formidable competitors when it comes to services.

But more importantly, the economics don't add up for the majority of companies using Android. Few are competing profitably, with Samsung and HTC the enviable exceptions. Add to this Android's accessibility and the burgeoning number of licensees, and falling prices become inevitable. Good for Google, but bad for manufacturers.

The backdrop to CES in this context is HTC's challenges in the fourth quarter of 2011. HTC is by no means on the ropes, but its financial results do reveal the fundamental problem for all Android manufacturers. The appearance of Peter Chou, HTC's CEO, alongside Steve Ballmer to reveal the Windows Phone-powered Titan 2 is little surprise in light of these challenges.

If these dynamics aren't enough of a problem, intellectual property disputes are further rocking the good ship Android. They'll play out for some time to come, but could well be the final straw if royalties and licence costs further strain gross margins.

Google intends to buy Motorola Mobility to strengthen its patent position. But given the predicament of many of its partners, it is surely also an insurance policy that will allow it to push its own agenda should support for Android begin to wane.

Android won't see a sudden and dramatic decline in market share. However, it's hard to see how it can continue to accommodate such a vast number of manufacturers when the economics favour a precious few. There are of course few alternatives, but the scenario certainly validates Stephen Elop's case for a "third ecosystem".

As counterintuitive as it seems, the sheer weight of support for Android at CES could be more to Microsoft's long-term advantage than Google's.

This entry was posted on January 12th, 2012 and is filed under Services. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Posted By Geoff Blaber On January 12th, 2012


Comments
Jonas
- 2012-01-12 at 09:07
I can not see how manufacturers can differentiate more with Windows phone than with Android. There is no benefit for consumer in having many different OSs. Differentiation needs to happen in HW and services (not trivial but it is the only way IMHO).
WP
- 2012-01-16 at 09:15
Is this paid by MSFT? You have totally forgotten the bigger picture. As was seen in CES whole home is becoming connected and frankly after game consoles move to handsets MSFT is left with phones and PC/laptops whilst Android is used everywhere. how is that in benefit of MSFT? if I were them I would be really worried...
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
Boston start-up MarkForged's 3D printers use carbon fibre, fibreglass and Kevlar for strong, functional products http://t.co/xNCQFXfd5s
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @paolopescatore: For now, Sky is the undisputed leader in triple play services. Without mobile, it was vulnerable in the future given re…
Follow Shaun
Martin Garner
Amazon announces WorkMail managed enterprise email service on AWS - pay per mailbox.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
Google now walking a similar tightrope as Amazon in justifying long term investment versus costs and near term returns.
Follow Geoff
Arnaud Gagneux
CEOs of some IT companies seem to be getting better results than elected politicians in some countries. Swap jobs?
Follow Arnaud
Paolo Pescatore
Our @ccsinsight take on Sky's Plans to Offer Mobile Services http://t.co/LfQpmYXNuH (login req'd). Sky remains a takeover target 4 Vodafone!
Follow Paolo
Marina Koytcheva
@feraldata Thank you for the insightful and thought provoking presentation today! Real pleasure and quite unusual for a tech event!
Follow Marina
Kester Mann
Sky is in an interesting position in the UK with close ties to both Vodafone (Sky Sports on 4G, Now TV) and now O2 (MVNO deal)
Follow Kester
Jasdeep Badyal
Glad the @Dell Venue 8 7000 tablet got some recognition and won engadget Best for Mobile. Classy product. #CES2015
Follow Jasdeep
George Jijiashvili
@zurichcharlie @benwood @jabrasport Nice, I haven't tried that yet. I did update the firmware though and seems more responsive now. Cheers!
Follow George
Rebecca Morley
RT @kestermann: Hutchison confirms negotiations to buy O2 in deal that will transform UK mobile landscape (and as predicted by @CCSInsight
Follow Rebecca

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
Carbon Copies Printing Parts as Strong as Metal The use of 3D printers ... Read more
Blog Post
Wi-Fi's Going Prime Time US Cable Operator Challenges Cellular Cablevision — a U... Read more
Blog Post
European Regulators Set for Tough Juggling Act in 2015 Plans by Hutchison to Buy O2 Will Create Headache for Author... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Worldwide Tablet Sales to Hit 540 Million Units in 2018 Windows Picks up Speed, but Could Still Fall at the Next Hur... Read more
More news