Europe Tries to Shut the Google Stable Door

European Commission Prepares to Issue Judgement on Android

Tomorrow the European Commission is expected to deliver its decision following an investigation of Google's use of its Android operating system and its role in distributing accompanying apps and services. The case is being heralded as Google's "Microsoft moment", referring to the commission's edict in 2001 to stop Microsoft bundling its Internet Explorer browser with Windows.

The decision is likely to be backed by a sizeable fine that will grab headlines. However, what it means for the future of Android and the way in which apps and services are distributed is highly uncertain. The size and scale of the Android ecosystem, coupled with the business model interdependencies of Google, manufacturers, operators and app developers, mean the case is decidedly more complex than that of Microsoft's Internet Explorer bundling. There's a substantial risk that despite the commission's best intentions, its action results in unintended consequences that ultimately penalize the consumer.

The strength of Google's position has invited increased scrutiny by the European Commission. In the wake of the 2017 verdict on Google Shopping results, Android was a natural next target. With more than 2 billion active devices and stringent requirements for manufacturers about how Android is used when coupled with Google apps and services, it is unsurprising the commission has sought to take action.

Although an open-source operating system, Android was introduced as a vehicle for Google's licensable apps and services and to extend Google's business model as engagement shifted to mobile devices. In this context, Android has been incredibly successful.

And yet Europe's stance is arguably six to eight years too late. The commission is shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted. A related problem is that there is no clear alternative to Android. Apple's iOS is an alternative from a consumer perspective, but Google has definitively beaten any licensable alternatives. Had the commission's determination been made even five years ago, it would have opened a door of opportunity for others such as Microsoft. Today most contenders are themselves built on an Android code base.

Although a move to separate apps from the operating system may help foster competition over the longer term, Android has served its purpose in cementing Google services in consumers' minds. At least in the West, manufacturers will still have to offer Google services to be competitive and meet consumer demand. Even if devices are shipped without these apps, users will seek them out. Any move to unbundle Google apps from the platform is likely to have limited impact on competition, at least in the short to medium term.

However, such a move would be likely to dent Google's ability to control Android and limit fragmentation. Google's apps and services have been the avenue through which Google has policed the Android ecosystem. Access to these services comes with certain requirements, meaning manufacturers follow stipulations on how Android is implemented. This includes limitations on Android versions and a requirement that manufacturers do not offer forked versions of Android. This was a particular focus of the European Commission's investigation.

Although Google comes under frequent attack for the extent of fragmentation in Android, it has in fact used its carrot and stick to great effect given the size and breadth of the ecosystem. Losing this control could prove detrimental to Google, manufacturers and ultimately consumers. The consequences are potentially wide-ranging. The commission's decision could simply mean that fragmentation worsens, resulting in inconsistent app performance and a poorer user experience for consumers.

However, it could also see Google deciding to change or adapt the Android business model if it concludes that open-source development is no longer feasible, practical or economically viable. The cost of software development for manufacturers has fallen considerably in the past 10 years. An element that the ruling may overlook is the role Android has played in enabling competition and radically reducing the cost of hardware. It's not inconceivable that hardware gets more expensive if the Android model changes.

This is just a summary of the factors at play. We caution that the European Commission should take a broad and pragmatic view of the complexity of the Android ecosystem, its interdependencies and relationship to Google's business model. Google's strength is an understandable concern, but overly arbitrary measures could ultimately hurt the consumer and only strengthen the position of a primary competitor in Apple.

This entry was posted on July 17th, 2018 and is filed under Devices. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed or you can leave a response.

Posted By Geoff Blaber On July 17th, 2018

(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
Can network operators convince people to connect a second line for companion devices like the tiny new Palm?…
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @GSMA: Is your company revolutionising the capabilities of #mobiletech? Apply for the 2019 #GLOMOAwards for your chance to win the Best…
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
RT @CCSInsight: Can network operators convince people to connect a second line for companion devices like the tiny new Palm?…
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
Great signage in the exhibition halls at #IoTSwC18 in Barcelona.
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
Agree 100%. I can’t think of any other consumer company that has elevated privacy to a product feature
Follow Geoff
Marina Koytcheva
Facial recognition will be just one of the technologies traditional retail will deploy to stay competitive with onl…
Follow Marina
Nicholas McQuire
A great @paulhewerdine @earnestagency summary capturing the breadth of #CCSPredicts
Follow Nicholas
Angela Ashenden
According to our 2018 survey, @WhatsApp is the most used mobile app by employees for work. That's a serious concer…
Follow Angela
Kester Mann
Hot off the press! @CCSInsight’s latest #5G update. News, analysis, status-updates and deployment schedules. A to-t…
Follow Kester
George Jijiashvili
RT @benwood: Just published on @CCSInsight daily blog. My take on Huawei’s news today. ”These announcements confirm Huawei's seat at the to…
Follow George
Laura Simeonova
RT @benwood: P20 devices testament to Huawei's ambition in smartphone market. Consistently improving design, capabilities and appeal of its…
Follow Laura
Katie Taylor
An important thread to dive into if you're at all unclear on the current state of Brexit and the outcomes of our op…
Follow Katie

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
Small Ambitions Is the Tiny Palm Phone the Start of a Big Trend? This wee... Read more
Blog Post
A World without Traffic Lights Can Cities Really Get This Smart? In a world where ever... Read more
Blog Post
Huawei Squares Up to Smartphone Rivals Adds New Mate 20 Series Devices to Its Arsenal I've attende... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Networks' Ambitions to Launch 5G Early Raise Global Forecast New CCS Insight forecast predicts 5G connections will reac... Read more
More news