Three's Smarty: Pants or Tops, Dude?

Operator Can Draw Inspiration from a Former Disruptive MVNO


This month, UK mobile network operator Three announced the launch of Smarty, its new sub-brand, adding yet another entity that somewhat mimics a mobile virtual network operator (MVNO) to a sizeable and fascinating market.

The MVNO model started in the 1990s as a way for a provider to offer mobile communications services without needing to own network infrastructure. An MVNO in the UK can simply purchase network airtime from one of the four mobile operators and sell services to customers under its own brand and supported by its own customer care systems.

The UK market for MVNOs is considerable in size. CCS Insight estimates that there are more than 100 virtual operators in the country — although some are admittedly very small and niche — with just under 12 million subscribers.

Branding is crucial to the success or failure of an MVNO. The first such provider in the UK, Virgin Mobile, is still going strong after 18 years and has about 3 million customers. At the time of launch, parent Virgin was one of the coolest and most relevant brands in the country and this was undoubtedly at the centre of the virtual operator's rise.

The other ingredient for success involves the target audience. MVNOs are often spawned out of parent companies that sell other services to existing customers displaying strong brand loyalty. The parent launches the MVNO — sometimes independently or sometimes with another shareholder — to this customer segment and new potential subscribers with a branded mobile service. For example, the supermarket chains of Asda, Sainsbury's and Tesco all have MVNOs.

There's a broad range of virtual operators and similar entities in the UK. Telecom companies offering broadband or landline services have introduced MVNOs: BT (before its EE acquisition), Carphone Warehouse, Gamma Telecom, Kingston Communications, Plusnet, TalkTalk and Telecom Plus all now provide mobile services. Other MVNOs target specific customer segments, for example, Lebara's offering has an international focus and The People's Operator and Age UK both have a charity bias.

More recently, Sky Mobile launched a service to much fanfare, although I was surprised that it didn't bundle access to Sky TV programming with the original packages. Over time, this may become an important differentiating factor in this increasingly competitive market.

Three is positioning Smarty as a low-cost sub-brand and a potential market disruptor. To succeed, Smarty will need a strong brand message, and to target its customers with a clear and coherent marketing campaign, as well as very attractive tariff structures.

I've worked with MVNOs in Africa, Asia and Europe, and to this day, my favourite remains a brilliant market disruptor called One.Tel, which started its life in the UK in the late 1990s as an Internet service provider. Led by visionary CEO Jodee Rich, it quickly became an MVNO, and profitable in its second year. Its brand image used a mascot called the "Dude", an Australian surfer cartoon character who wore baggy shorts and tops. The company targeted aspirational "dudes" in the UK, young international residents and consumers looking for an inexpensive alternative to BT and Vodafone. It offered low, simple tariffs, great customer care and a completely different experience to that offered by mobile network operators at the time. One.Tel was young, cool, simple and successful.

Sadly, the Australian parent of One.Tel UK went into administration in 2001, ironically as it tried to migrate from an MVNO to a full mobile network operator. The UK business was sold to British Gas and then in turn to TalkTalk, where there are still legacy One.Tel staff and customers today.

Fashions change with time and although the Dude may not be the best brand image for Smarty, what One.Tel achieved in its few years in the UK is very relevant to Three and its plans for its sub-brand. The operator needs to get the right branding strategy, innovate with tariff structures and data packages, pursue a specific customer segment and keep things fun and simple.

This entry was posted on August 29th, 2017 and is filed under Services. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed or you can leave a response.

Posted By Tony Worthington On August 29th, 2017


Comments
(There are no comments yet)
Leave a Comment

Hot News

Team Tweets

CCS Insight
A look at the next wave of collaboration tools hoping to solve the problem of technology overload in the workplace,… https://t.co/ZapufOw90k
Follow CCS Insight
Shaun Collins
RT @kestermann: Total UK mobile data traffic continues to show strong growth on 4G (now tailing off on 3G). @CCSInsight’s latest UK forecas…
Follow Shaun
Ben Wood
Quick shout out to Crissia in the @FitBark team for the excellent support today. Was having some problems correctly… https://t.co/F1bGOF30nX
Follow Ben
Martin Garner
Very interesting briefing just now with @retarus on "information logistics" - the Industrial IoT world increasingly… https://t.co/n1JIKDsX8e
Follow Martin
Geoff Blaber
Oh my.. The Verizon Y branding has now vanished entirely.. What happened to "doubling down and focusing on the netw… https://t.co/5K38Zmj1zG
Follow Geoff
Marina Koytcheva
Well done to @giffgaff for turning the outage PR nightmare into a positive story! Almost 39% of members chose t… https://t.co/Op5u3IZeWu
Follow Marina
Nicholas McQuire
Which tech brand does IT trust the most with their company data? #Microsoft now leaps ahead of the rest - includi… https://t.co/IMvfLRSmYK
Follow Nicholas
Kester Mann
RT @MarinaKoytcheva: Well done to @giffgaff for turning the outage PR nightmare into a positive story! Almost 39% of members chose to d…
Follow Kester
Angela Ashenden
RT @nickmcquire: Which tech brand does IT trust the most with their company data? #Microsoft now leaps ahead of the rest - including secu…
Follow Angela
George Jijiashvili
RT @MarinaKoytcheva: Great job opportunity for a quantitative analyst: @CCSInsight is looking for a smart person to join our market forecas…
Follow George
Katie Taylor
RT @bengoldacre: In 2017 @NHSengland published a list of things GPs should not prescribe. Six months on, we checked the data to see what i…
Follow Katie

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post
Postmates' Food Delivery Bot Robots Like This Could Be the Future of Delivery Postmates ... Read more
Blog Post
The Digital Workplace Hub The Next Wave in Collaboration The collaboration software m... Read more
Blog Post
The Money Trail The Bane of Location Tracking We gain a lot from smartphone... Read more
More blog

Latest Company News

Blog Post
Virtual Reality Device Market Declines in 2018 But Outlook Remains Positive Research firm CCS Insight forecasts 8 million virtual realit... Read more
More news